Description of arts therapies practice with adults suffering from depression in the UK

Qualitative findings from the nationwide survey

Ania Zubala (Lead / Corresponding author), Donald J. MacIntyre, Nigel Gleeson, Vicky Karkou

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    5 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    There is growing evidence that arts therapies present a relevant treatment option for depression but, the experiences, methods, tools and ways of working of arts therapists with this client group remain unclear. Thus, this research study aimed to describe the specifics of arts therapies practice with depression. In 2011 all arts therapists registered in the UK were invited to complete an online questionnaire concerning their practice in general and in relation to depression. The Arts Therapies Survey received 395 responses. Arts therapists who work primarily with depression were identified and compared to those who do not work with depression on a range of factors. These quantitative results were presented elsewhere (Zubala, MacIntyre, Gleeson & Karkou, 2013). Analysis of qualitative material was guided by the strategy of grounded theory and findings were obtained through thematic analysis. The current paper introduces these findings, adding depth to the knowledge previously gained through quantitative analysis. Arts therapists worked across various settings with highly complex clients, but struggled with the tension of providing care according to guidelines, which they found inflexible and at times misguided. Therapists tended to vary the theoretical model of their therapeutic approach depending on individual client factors and often collaborated with other professionals using a variety of standardised tools to measure outcomes. The findings further offer a detailed understanding of the therapeutic process and describe the meaning of clinical practice within arts therapies.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)535-544
    Number of pages10
    JournalThe Arts in Psychotherapy
    Volume41
    Issue number5
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Nov 2014

    Keywords

    • Depression
    • Arts therapies
    • Survey
    • UK
    • Clinical practice
    • Therapeutic process

    Cite this

    Zubala, Ania ; MacIntyre, Donald J. ; Gleeson, Nigel ; Karkou, Vicky. / Description of arts therapies practice with adults suffering from depression in the UK : Qualitative findings from the nationwide survey. In: The Arts in Psychotherapy. 2014 ; Vol. 41, No. 5. pp. 535-544.
    @article{2933974e9d4c4dce90dc0955ce561598,
    title = "Description of arts therapies practice with adults suffering from depression in the UK: Qualitative findings from the nationwide survey",
    abstract = "There is growing evidence that arts therapies present a relevant treatment option for depression but, the experiences, methods, tools and ways of working of arts therapists with this client group remain unclear. Thus, this research study aimed to describe the specifics of arts therapies practice with depression. In 2011 all arts therapists registered in the UK were invited to complete an online questionnaire concerning their practice in general and in relation to depression. The Arts Therapies Survey received 395 responses. Arts therapists who work primarily with depression were identified and compared to those who do not work with depression on a range of factors. These quantitative results were presented elsewhere (Zubala, MacIntyre, Gleeson & Karkou, 2013). Analysis of qualitative material was guided by the strategy of grounded theory and findings were obtained through thematic analysis. The current paper introduces these findings, adding depth to the knowledge previously gained through quantitative analysis. Arts therapists worked across various settings with highly complex clients, but struggled with the tension of providing care according to guidelines, which they found inflexible and at times misguided. Therapists tended to vary the theoretical model of their therapeutic approach depending on individual client factors and often collaborated with other professionals using a variety of standardised tools to measure outcomes. The findings further offer a detailed understanding of the therapeutic process and describe the meaning of clinical practice within arts therapies.",
    keywords = "Depression, Arts therapies, Survey, UK, Clinical practice, Therapeutic process",
    author = "Ania Zubala and MacIntyre, {Donald J.} and Nigel Gleeson and Vicky Karkou",
    year = "2014",
    month = "11",
    doi = "10.1016/j.aip.2014.10.005",
    language = "English",
    volume = "41",
    pages = "535--544",
    journal = "The Arts in Psychotherapy",
    issn = "0197-4556",
    publisher = "Elsevier",
    number = "5",

    }

    Description of arts therapies practice with adults suffering from depression in the UK : Qualitative findings from the nationwide survey. / Zubala, Ania (Lead / Corresponding author); MacIntyre, Donald J.; Gleeson, Nigel; Karkou, Vicky.

    In: The Arts in Psychotherapy, Vol. 41, No. 5, 11.2014, p. 535-544.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Description of arts therapies practice with adults suffering from depression in the UK

    T2 - Qualitative findings from the nationwide survey

    AU - Zubala, Ania

    AU - MacIntyre, Donald J.

    AU - Gleeson, Nigel

    AU - Karkou, Vicky

    PY - 2014/11

    Y1 - 2014/11

    N2 - There is growing evidence that arts therapies present a relevant treatment option for depression but, the experiences, methods, tools and ways of working of arts therapists with this client group remain unclear. Thus, this research study aimed to describe the specifics of arts therapies practice with depression. In 2011 all arts therapists registered in the UK were invited to complete an online questionnaire concerning their practice in general and in relation to depression. The Arts Therapies Survey received 395 responses. Arts therapists who work primarily with depression were identified and compared to those who do not work with depression on a range of factors. These quantitative results were presented elsewhere (Zubala, MacIntyre, Gleeson & Karkou, 2013). Analysis of qualitative material was guided by the strategy of grounded theory and findings were obtained through thematic analysis. The current paper introduces these findings, adding depth to the knowledge previously gained through quantitative analysis. Arts therapists worked across various settings with highly complex clients, but struggled with the tension of providing care according to guidelines, which they found inflexible and at times misguided. Therapists tended to vary the theoretical model of their therapeutic approach depending on individual client factors and often collaborated with other professionals using a variety of standardised tools to measure outcomes. The findings further offer a detailed understanding of the therapeutic process and describe the meaning of clinical practice within arts therapies.

    AB - There is growing evidence that arts therapies present a relevant treatment option for depression but, the experiences, methods, tools and ways of working of arts therapists with this client group remain unclear. Thus, this research study aimed to describe the specifics of arts therapies practice with depression. In 2011 all arts therapists registered in the UK were invited to complete an online questionnaire concerning their practice in general and in relation to depression. The Arts Therapies Survey received 395 responses. Arts therapists who work primarily with depression were identified and compared to those who do not work with depression on a range of factors. These quantitative results were presented elsewhere (Zubala, MacIntyre, Gleeson & Karkou, 2013). Analysis of qualitative material was guided by the strategy of grounded theory and findings were obtained through thematic analysis. The current paper introduces these findings, adding depth to the knowledge previously gained through quantitative analysis. Arts therapists worked across various settings with highly complex clients, but struggled with the tension of providing care according to guidelines, which they found inflexible and at times misguided. Therapists tended to vary the theoretical model of their therapeutic approach depending on individual client factors and often collaborated with other professionals using a variety of standardised tools to measure outcomes. The findings further offer a detailed understanding of the therapeutic process and describe the meaning of clinical practice within arts therapies.

    KW - Depression

    KW - Arts therapies

    KW - Survey

    KW - UK

    KW - Clinical practice

    KW - Therapeutic process

    U2 - 10.1016/j.aip.2014.10.005

    DO - 10.1016/j.aip.2014.10.005

    M3 - Article

    VL - 41

    SP - 535

    EP - 544

    JO - The Arts in Psychotherapy

    JF - The Arts in Psychotherapy

    SN - 0197-4556

    IS - 5

    ER -